Greeley Bar Shooting Case Update: Jimmy Cazares Convicted of Attempted Murder

Several years after a startling incident at a Northern Colorado establishment, a suspect is facing a long list of charges.

A Greeley man has been found guilty in connection to a 2024 bar shooting.

Greeley Bar Shooting at Wyler's Pub and Grill: What Happened

Get our free mobile app

On November 20th, 2024, at 2:00 AM a shooting took place at Wyler's Pub and Grill.

Read More: A Long-Vacant Old Town Fort Collins Lot Is Finally Being Developed

Police Respond to Greeley Shooting: Victims and Damage Reported

According to reports, once law enforcement arrived on the scene, they found shell casings and bullet holes through the door of the business.

They also rescued the general manager Leah Neugebauer who survived the ordeal after undergoing emergency surgery.

Read More: Greeley Brewery’s Closure Turns Hopeful with Potential New Owner

Suspect Jimmy Cazares Arrested After Greeley Bar Incident

The suspect, 33-year-old Jimmy Cazares, had left the scene before officers arrived. He was later arrested without incident after a standoff at a nearby home.

Jimmy Cazares Found Guilty in 2024 Greeley Shooting Case

Fast forward to 2026, he has been tried and found guilty on all counts, including attempted first-degree murder for two victims, criminal mischief causing tens of thousands in damages, as well as five other charges involving weapons and drugs.

Read More: Greeley Voters to Decide Fate of $800M Entertainment District in February Election

Sentencing Set for April 2026 in Greeley Bar Shooting Case

Sentencing is set to take place on April 15th, 2026.

We will keep you updated as more information comes out regarding this full case.