2 Colorado Ice Cream Shops Make Yelp’s “Best in America” List

There are very few things that almost everyone can agree on.

While we all have different tastes or flavors that we prefer, I think we can all reach a consensus that ice cream is delicious.

Whether you have a more sophisticated palette or just love the classics, nothing hits better than snagging a scoop of ice cream on a hot day.

Get our free mobile app

Yelp’s Top 100 Ice Cream Shops for 2025

Yelp recently put together a list of the Top 100 Ice Cream Shops for 2025 and two spots in Colorado actually made the ranking!

This is based off of Yelp reviews left by customers, so the higher the ratings overall the better the spot is on this list.

Coming in with the #1 spot overall is a sweet spot in Phoenix, Arizona called Novel Ice Cream.

READ MORE: A Sweet New Spot Just Opened in Downtown Windsor

Two Colorado Ice Cream Shops Make Yelp's 2025 National List

States like California, Texas, and Florida have multiple entries on this list. Only two shops from the Centennial State cracked the top hundred on Yelp's ice cream ranking.

Caffeinated Cow in Colorado Springs Ranks #74 in the U.S.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Caffeinated Cow (@caffeinatedcow)

Coming in at #74 is the Caffeinated Cow in Colorado Springs. This is a family and veteran owned & operated business that locally sources their ingredients.

Why Caffeinated Cow Is a Colorado Favorite for Ice Cream and Coffee

With 123 reviews and a 4.8/5 ranking on Yelp, Caffeinated Cow offers coffee, ice cream, and even breakfast burritos! Now THAT is a classic Colorado staple!

Stir-Pan Creamery in Breckenridge Ranks #80 Nationwide

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Stir-Pan Creamery (@stirpan_creamery)

Coming in at 80 out of 100 on this list is Stir-Pan Creamery in Breckenridge.

Rolled Ice Cream and Unique Flavors at Breckenridge’s Stir-Pan Creamery

Stir Pan offers up rolled ice cream and flavors like French toast and keylime! To top it all off, this spot allows customers to build their own flavor and, "watch as our ice cream professional creates their dessert right in front of them."

There is also a Stir Pan location in Denver!

READ MORE: This Downtown Greeley Spot Is the Coolest New Date Night Idea

This ice cream spot's Yelp page has 220 reviews and a 4.7/5 rating overall! Not too shabby!

You can check out the full list of the best ice cream spots according to Yelp here.

Have you been to either of these places? Let us know what you thought of them by shooting us a message on the station app.

Stay up to date with everything going on in Northern Colorado and beyond by downloading the free station app from your app store.

Also, don't forget to follow the station across all social media platforms for the latest news and entertainment updates.